My Unconventional Picks for the Next Doctor. Who?

Who should play The Doctor? That is the question that has nerds across the world all in a tizzy. Article after article lists people’s guesses as to who will get the nod. What’s funny is that most of the articles list only super-famous people who I think would almost be too distracting. The great thing about Doctor Who is that the man playing the role has no baggage from previous jobs.

Rupert Grint as The Doctor? No way. The role should NOT go to a Weasley. And I say that as someone who loved Grint as Ron Weasley. But seriously, would YOU be able to get over the fact that The Doctor was being played by a Weasley?

Other names thrown around include Idris Elba, James Nesbitt, Helen Mirren, Chiwetel Ejiofor, and Russell Tovey (which, for me, is another NO NO NO because he’s ALONZO, for heaven’s sake!).

No, I think The Doctor should be relatively unknown, or someone that, when you first hear his name you say, “Who is HE?” and the response you get is, “He’s the guy – the one in that thing. You know, the guy in the thing.” After all, who really knew who Matt Smith was before he was cast, other than his mother and a few co-workers he had back in the day?

So here are a few of my picks, in no particular order. And yes, all are from the UK:

Ben Barnes
See? You don’t know who he is, do you? His name is just generic enough that you don’t quite know. Well, let me remind you. He was Prince Caspian in the “The Chronicles of Narnia” movie. He’s not necessarily a household name, and he’s done a nice mix of action (“Narnia”) and drama (“Dorian Grey”). He’s done TV before (early in his career) and despite filming movies even now, I think he might be an interesting pick.

Joseph Morgan
Another one of those “huh? names. But fans of “The Vampire Diaries” know exactly who Joseph Morgan is. As Klaus on “Diaries” he brings a proper amount of menace and vulnerability while others around him sometimes chew the scenery. The writing for Klaus isn’t always good, but Morgan never disappoints. His character has become one of my favorites because he’s one of the few that has depth bcause of the man playing the role.
joseph morgan

Ioan Gruffudd
Gruffudd is more well-known due to “Horatio Hornblower” and “Fantastic Four,” but people are unable to pronounce his name. Making him The Doctor will enable the entire world to finally know how to pronounce this Welshman’s name properly! Despite the slightly higher profile, I don’t think Gruffudd would bring baggage with him to the show and he’s just a really great actor.
Ioan Gruffud

Brendan Gleeson
I know the Doctors have been getting younger with each regeneration, but perhaps they can go older and grittier? Sure, he played Mad-Eye Moody in Harry Potter, but Gleeson is definitely a character actor. He’s done action (“28 Days Later”) and drama (“Cold Mountain”) and has proven himself to be a mix of tough and touching if the role calls for it. I think he’s the height of unconventional and could be really good.
brendan gleeson

Asa Butterfield
If you don’t know this kid yet, you are in for some great movies. I recommend “Hugo,” “The Boy in Striped Pajamas” and “Son of Rambow.” Butterfield works as The Doctor if they are going to continue the trend of having each Doctor be younger than the next. Matt Smith was 29 when cast as The Doctor. Why not make the new Doctor aged 19? Imagine current companion Clara having to follow a Doctor who is closer in age to herself in appearance and yet nearly 1,000 years old. I think that could be an interesting dynamic to play with. Alas, Butterfield is no doubt going to become huge once the upcoming “Ender’s Game” is released, and I doubt they’d even consider him just because he is so young.
asa butterfield

Charles Dance
Another choice should they go older. Another character actor like Gleeson, Dance almost always plays roles who are villains, and does it quite well. Tennant and Smith both hinted at a much darker Doctor – imagine what Doctor Dance could do! It’s a shame he’s on “Game of Thrones” right now, because I think he’d make an outstanding Doctor.
charles dance

Others I’d love to see (and whose names have been bandied about for the role), but I think they are too high profile, include Martin Freeman (who has had a great couple of years with “Sherlock” and “The Hobbit”), Richard Armitage (“The Hobbit, “MI-5”), Tom Hiddleston (“Thor”), Tom Hardy (“Inception”), and Paul Bettany (“The DaVinci Code, “Master and Commander”). Before he was cast as this year’s Superman, I’d have said Henry Cavill would be a great choice, even though, to be honest, I don’t think The Doctor should be so in-your-face good looking.

Gratuitous Henry Cavill picture.
Gratuitous Henry Cavill picture.

My Signature

If you liked that post, read on...

Tivo Continues to Rule on May 9th, 2005

Gone Gone Gone on October 17th, 2007

TV: Ace Was Right on May 22nd, 2006

Television: Father of the Pride on September 28th, 2004


  1. I think the next Doctor needs to be older. Smith was 27 when he was cast, actually – he only just turned 30.

    Gleeson – yes! That’s a great pick. Won’t happen.

    Dance is another interesting choice. Again, I don’t see it happening.

    Rory Kinnear is the name I see the most. And I read somewhere that UK bookies favor him.

  2. I’ve seen Rory Kinnear mentioned. Also, Joseph Paterson. Paterson was GREAT in “Survivors,” which for a while was available on Netflix streaming (I recommend it although the second season wasn’t as good as the first). I read that Patterson was a front-runner for 11 until Matt Smith auditioned and bowled everyone over. He is helped by the fact that he’s been on DW before in Nine’s season.

  3. *lol* Amy, you should give it a go again anyway! C’mon! It’s great! How about I recommend some bottle episodes that don’t require you know any history about the characters? I can give you a bit of a Top 10 list to check out.

  4. Okay, here’s my top ten (in chronological order of airing). I’ll skip Season 1 and just go straight to Season 2:

    Season 2:
    Ep. 4: The Girl in the Fireplace
    Ep. 11: Fear Her

    Season 3:
    Ep. 8: Human Nature
    Ep. 9: Family of Blood
    Ep. 10: Blink (my favorite episode of all time)

    Season 4:
    Ep. 7: The Unicorn and the Wasp
    Ep. 8: Midnight (my second favorite episode of all time)

    Season 5:
    Ep. 1: The Eleventh Hour
    Ep. 10: Vincent and the Doctor (my third favorite episode of all time)

    Season 6:
    Ep. 10: The Girl Who Waited

    Most of those are bottle episodes that don’t deal with the larger season-long story arc. S3-Ep8/9 is a two-parter that should definitely be watched together.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Are you human? Solve this equation and prove it! * Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.